Posted by: Saving Water SA (Cape Town, South Africa) – partnered with Water Rhapsody conservation systems – 09 May 2010
South Africa’s organic farming industry is up in arms over international research that claims organic farming harms wildlife and produces less food – and that its produce is no healthier than conventionally farmed foods.
The popularity of organic foods – produced naturally without pesticides and potentially harmful fertilisers – has soared in South Africa in recent years.
But research conducted by the University of Leeds in England found that organic farms produced less than half as much food compared with conventional farming and needed twice as much land to produce the same amount of food.
The study also showed there were 10% fewer small birds, such as yellowhammers, corn buntings, linnets, skylarks and lapwings, in organic fields in the UK. Researchers found that larger birds, which were attracted to dense organic crops, were scaring away the smaller birds, disrupting the ecosystem.
But that was not the worst of it. A recent review commissioned by the UK Food Standards Agency found that organic food was neither more nutritious nor healthier than conventionally farmed food.
Said the agency’s Gill Fine: “This study does not mean that people should not eat organic food. What it shows is that there is little, if any, nutritional difference … there is no evidence of additional health benefits from eating organic food.”
But local experts have slammed both reports. Durban agricultural scientist Dr Raymond Auberbach said that, contrary to the study’s findings, organic farming was beneficial to birdlife, adding that conventional farming methods were wiping out birds of prey.
“Pesticides and other harmful chemicals are killing these birds. In fact, organic farming would be more beneficial to the birds and the ecosystem,” said Auberbach.
The head of the Biodiversity and Organic Certification Authority in Pretoria, Tim Jackson, said his farm was full of birds and wildlife.
He dismissed the findings on production levels as “hogwash”, saying they didn’t apply to South Africa. “We are producing twice as much maize. The output is now doubled from what we used to get using the conventional system. We never got produce like this … it is the most profitable kind of farming and the productivity is amazing.
“It has been accepted worldwide that organically farmed produce has 15% more nutrients than chemical farming.”
Diana Callear, head of local organic certification body Ecocert, said organic agriculture required good land management. She said in South Africa the labour intensity of organic agriculture was a plus, as well as reduced use of fuel energy and pesticides. “Furthermore, organic agriculture does not add to the already high level of pollution of our water systems,” she said.
She said studies had found there were more micronutrients in organically produced food.
– Subashni Naidoo
Source: Times Live